---
title: Court Finds Forest Service’s NEPA Analysis “Strains Reason”
description: A court recently rejected a Forest Service environmental analysis because the court found the agency engaged in speculation to reach its conclusion. The court held that while its review of determinations an agency makes in its National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) analyses is highly deferential, that deference is not unlimited. In this case, the court […]
---
[Skip to main content](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/court-find-forest-services-nepa-analysis-strains-reason#main)
[   ](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com)
- Show submenu for About Garden Law About Garden Law
- [About the Garden Law Firm and Kevin](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/about)
- [Bars, Courts, & Cases](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/garden-law-bars-courts-and-cases)
- Show submenu for Practice Areas Practice Areas
- [Concessioners, Guides, & Outfitters](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/legal-assistance-for-concessioners-guides-and-outfitters-on-federal-land)
- [Federal Land Use Issues](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/federal-land-use-issues)
- [Government Contracts & Bid Protests](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/government-contracts-bid-protests)
- Show submenu for DIY Legal Resources DIY Legal Resources
- [Garden Law Resource Center](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/garden-law-resource-center)
- [The Concessioners Toolbox](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/the-concessioners-toolbox-diy-legal-resources-for-concessioners)
- [From The Garden Blog](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden)
Open main navigation
Close main navigation
- Show submenu for About Garden Law About Garden Law
- About Garden Law
- [About the Garden Law Firm and Kevin](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/about)
- [Bars, Courts, & Cases](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/garden-law-bars-courts-and-cases)
- Show submenu for Practice Areas Practice Areas
- Practice Areas
- [Concessioners, Guides, & Outfitters](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/legal-assistance-for-concessioners-guides-and-outfitters-on-federal-land)
- [Federal Land Use Issues](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/federal-land-use-issues)
- [Government Contracts & Bid Protests](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/government-contracts-bid-protests)
- Show submenu for DIY Legal Resources DIY Legal Resources
- DIY Legal Resources
- [Garden Law Resource Center](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/garden-law-resource-center)
- [The Concessioners Toolbox](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/the-concessioners-toolbox-diy-legal-resources-for-concessioners)
- [From The Garden Blog](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden)
- Search
- [Contact Kevin](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/contact-garden-law)
[Contact Kevin](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/contact-garden-law)
Search
[The Garden Law Firm Blog](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden)
Categories
[Subscribe!](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/sign-up-for-the-latest-news-from-garden-law)
- [Industry News](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/industry-news)
- [Case Commentaries](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/case-commentaries)
- [Alerts](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/alerts)
- [Forest Service](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service)
- [Forest Service campground concessions](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service-campground-concessions)
- [campground prospectus](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/campground-prospectus)
- [encroachment](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/encroachment)
- [federal contract minimum wage](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/federal-contract-minimum-wage)
- [BLM leases](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/blm-leases)
- [FLPMA](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/flpma)
- [Forest Service helicopter](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service-helicopter)
- [Forest Service outfitter](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service-outfitter)
- [Forest Service small business set-aside](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service-small-business-set-aside)
# Court Finds Forest Service’s NEPA Analysis “Strains Reason”
A court recently rejected a Forest Service environmental analysis because the court found the agency engaged in speculation to reach its conclusion. The court held that while its review of determinations an agency makes in its National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) analyses is highly deferential, that deference is not unlimited. In this case, the court found that the Forest Service’s determinations strained reason and were “a stretch.” As a result, the court rejected the NEPA analysis.
The case involved an Environmental Assessment regarding the impact of snowmobiling on mountain goats, lynx and wolverines within the Sawtooth National Forest. The Forest Service selected an alternative based on the need to prevent disturbances to mountain goats, protect mapped and predicted lynx habitat and reduce disturbances to wolverine dens. The court determined that agency’s selected was unreasonable because no lynx had ever been documented in the area at issue and the agency’s conclusion was entirely “speculative.” In addition, the Forest Service merely assumed wolverine dens existed in the area but all of their analyses showed that none any actually did. Finally, the court noted that the agency found that mountain goats sought out rocky, rugged terrain and low snow conditions, and thus were not likely to interact with snowmobiles. Thus, the court found the agency’s determination that its selection was based on its need to limit interaction with mountain goats as “somewhat odd.” The court then rejected the EA finding that “while the Forest Service has done substantial work on this project, its conclusions are, frankly, a stretch based upon the evidence in the record.”
**Tags:**
[Case Commentaries](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/case-commentaries)
Post by [Kevin Garden](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/author/kevin-garden)
Whether you're a large-scale concessioner, a small family business, a guide, an outfitter, or an individual doing business or recreating on federal land, Kevin Garden has the experience and perspective to help.
[Follow me on my website](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com) [Follow me on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100066387593247) [Follow me on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/kevin-garden-1315b330/) [Follow me on Twitter](https://twitter.com/gardenlawfirm)
### Related Articles
##### [ Case Commentaries Supreme Court Narrows Scope Of Impacts To Be Evaluated Under NEPA 1 min read](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/supreme-court-narrows-scope-of-impacts-to-be-evaluated-under-nepa)
##### [ Forest Service Court Suspends Forest Service From Enforcing Its Decision To Deny A Special Use Permit 1 min read](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/court-suspends-forest-service-from-enforcing-its-decision-to-deny-a-special-use-permit)
##### [ Forest Service Court Clarifies Forest Service and Campground Permittee Liability For Injuries To Visitors 1 min read](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/court-clarifies-forest-service-and-campground-permittee-liability-for-injuries-to-visitors)
### Sign up for news from Garden Law
Make informed decisions in your business as a concessioner, guide, or outfitter on federal lands. Subscribe to From the Garden blog to stay up to date!
###### Categories
- [Industry News](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/industry-news)
- [Case Commentaries](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/case-commentaries)
- [Alerts](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/alerts)
- [Forest Service](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service)
- [Forest Service campground concessions](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/tag/forest-service-campground-concessions)
###### Recent Posts
- [New Federal Contractor Minimum Wage Requires Government To Compensate Procurement Contractor](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/new-federal-contractor-minimum-wage-requires-government-to-compensate-procurement-contractor)
- [US Forest Service Is Incorporating AI Into Its Environmental Reviews Of Infrastructure Projects](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/us-forest-service-is-incorporating-ai-into-its-environmental-reviews-of-infrastructure-projects)
- [Forest Service Approves Private Construction Of A New Recreation Facility Under A Term Permit](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/forest-service-approves-private-construction-of-a-new-recreation-facility-under-a-term-permit)
- [Court Finds Forest Service Regulation Prohibiting Unauthorized Commercial Activity Invalid In The Case Of A Social Media Influencer](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/court-finds-forest-service-regulation-prohibiting-unauthorized-commercial-activity-invalid-in-the-case-of-a-social-media-influencer)
- [National Park Service Requests Cuts To Its Own Budget](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/national-park-service-requests-cuts-to-its-own-budget)
[](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com)
66 Canal Center Plaza, Suite 505
Alexandria, VA 22314
Tel: (703) 535-5565
-
-
-
- Explore Garden Law
- [About](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/about)
- [Legal Notices](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/garden-law-website-legal-notices)
- [Contact Us](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/contact-garden-law)
- Resources
- [From the Garden Blog](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden)
- [The Concessioner's Toolbox](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/the-concessioners-toolbox-diy-legal-resources-for-concessioners)
- [Sign up for News from Garden Law](https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/sign-up-for-the-latest-news-from-garden-law)
©2026 The Garden Law Firm, P.C. All rights reserved.
```json
{
"@context" : "https://schema.org",
"@type" : "BlogPosting",
"author" : {
"@type" : "Person",
"name" : "Kevin Garden",
"url" : "https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/author/kevin-garden"
},
"dateModified" : "2025-01-07T20:49:38.228Z",
"datePublished" : "2021-10-28T13:45:28.000Z",
"headline" : "Court Finds Forest Service’s NEPA Analysis “Strains Reason”",
"mainEntityOfPage" : {
"@id" : "https://www.gardenlawfirm.com/from-the-garden/court-find-forest-services-nepa-analysis-strains-reason",
"@type" : "WebPage"
},
"publisher" : {
"@type" : "Organization",
"logo" : {
"@type" : "ImageObject"
}
}
}
```