Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Kevin is on the Board of the National Forest Recreation Association. He has appeared before numerous federal district courts in litigation of government claims and federal land management issues. Contact Kevin to find out how he can help you.
Contact Kevin Today
Court Finds That BLM Must Return Mining Maintenance Fees
Your Government counsel.™
A federal court required the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to return annual maintenance fees which it had improperly charged to a holder of 87 lode mining claims in Idaho. In 2011, Congress changed the applicable law so that pre-1993 claim holders no longer had to pay claim maintenance fees, but instead had to complete a minimum amount of assessment work. However, BLM disregarded the change in the law and issued regulations that required pre-1993 claim holders to continue paying maintenance fees to the government. The government asserted various defenses to avoid being liable for its clearly erroneous regulations, but the court rejected each of these.
The government first argued that the plaintiff had voluntarily paid the fees and therefore the voluntary payment doctrine applied and prevented the plaintiff from filing a claim that the government had illegally exacted the fees. The court rejected this argument, pointing out that there was no voluntary payment and the doctrine did not apply where the government demanded the payment in violation of a statute intended to benefit the claim holder. The government also argued that the plaintiff would get a windfall because, if it had not paid the fees, it should have completed assessment work but did not. The court held that, when the government acts beyond its statutory authority to collect money, it is irrelevant if a plaintiff obtains a windfall when it recoups the erroneously paid funds.
Share this post
Subscribe to the mailing list
Find out how The Garden Law Firm can help you today!
Temporary Reprieve From Wildfire Insurance Coverage For Forest Service Campground and Day Use Permits
The US Forest Service recently issued a letter asking Regional Foresters to consider requests from holders of campground and day use permits for a one
Forest Service Cancels Campground Prospectus After Erroneously Listing It As A Small Business Set-Aside
The Forest Service recently decided to withdraw a prospectus for a campground permit after the agency had “mistakenly marked” the prospectus as a small business
Forest Service Revises Solicitation For Helicopter Wildfire Support In Light Of Protest
The Forest Service recently cancelled a solicitation for helicopter wildfire support and agreed to review its documentation justifying its proposed evaluation method in light of
Categories
Archives